You are married to a U.S. citizen or a green card holder, and you have a Notice to Appear. Whether the marriage came before or after the NTA, the first question is the same: who decides my green card now, the immigration judge or USCIS? As of October 2026 the answer is both, in a fixed order set by regulation. Getting that order right is the difference between a case that moves and one that sits for years.
This post explains which agency holds which form, what changes if you were paroled, the standard for a marriage entered after the case began, what happened to administrative closure in 2026, how the I-485 is filed and paid for in court, and what the judge's order does. If your case is still at USCIS, our post on translated documents and interpreters at the AOS interview covers that setting instead.
Two Agencies, Two Forms: Where the I-130 and the I-485 Actually Go
A marriage-based green card is always two decisions. The Form I-130 asks whether the marriage is real and whether your spouse is a citizen or permanent resident. The Form I-485 asks whether you are eligible and admissible. Outside of court, USCIS decides both; in removal proceedings they split.
The I-130 never leaves USCIS. Immigration judges have no authority to adjudicate visa petitions, as the Board restated in Matter of Hashmi, 24 I&N Dec. 785 (BIA 2009). Your spouse files it exactly as if you were not in proceedings.
The I-485 moves to the courtroom. Under 8 CFR 1245.2(a)(1)(i), for anyone placed in removal proceedings "other than as an arriving alien," the immigration judge "has exclusive jurisdiction to adjudicate any application for adjustment of status the alien may file." The DHS regulation at 8 CFR 245.2(a)(1) says the same thing from the other direction: USCIS has jurisdiction "unless the immigration judge has jurisdiction to adjudicate the application under 8 CFR 1245.2(a)(1)." Mail an I-485 to a lockbox while an NTA is pending and USCIS will not decide it.
The judge cannot grant adjustment until the I-130 is approved, because an immigrant visa must be immediately available, and for a spouse that comes from the approved petition. 8 CFR 1245.2(a)(2)(i)(B) lets the I-485 be filed in court while an immediate relative petition is pending, but the merits hearing waits for USCIS.
The Arriving Alien Exception: When USCIS Keeps Your Green Card Even in Court
The phrase "other than as an arriving alien" matters for a growing share of our clients. An arriving alien is, broadly, someone who was paroled into the United States rather than admitted: humanitarian parole, CBP One, advance parole.
For them the rule flips. Under 8 CFR 1245.2(a)(1)(ii), the judge "does not have jurisdiction to adjudicate any application for adjustment of status filed by the arriving alien" unless four things are all true: the person filed the I-485 with USCIS while in the United States, left and returned under advance parole to pursue it, USCIS denied it, and DHS placed the person in proceedings on the return or after the denial. In the ordinary case, a paroled spouse files the I-485 with USCIS even while the removal case is pending.
Matter of Yauri, 25 I&N Dec. 103 (BIA 2009), confirms it: with a narrow exception, USCIS "has exclusive jurisdiction to adjudicate an arriving alien's application for adjustment of status," and keeps it even where an unexecuted final order of removal is outstanding. For a paroled spouse, the two cases run in parallel, and the court case must not end in an order before USCIS acts.
Married After the NTA: The Clear and Convincing Standard
Congress presumes that a marriage entered during proceedings is suspect. INA 245(e)(1) bars adjustment based on a marriage entered during the period described in INA 245(e)(2): while administrative or judicial proceedings are pending on the person's right to be admitted or to remain. INA 245(e)(3) lifts the bar if you establish "by clear and convincing evidence" that the marriage "was entered into in good faith," was "not entered into for the purpose of procuring the alien's admission as an immigrant," and that no fee was paid for the petition other than attorney fees. INA 204(g) imposes the same standard on the I-130 itself.
The DHS regulation at 8 CFR 245.1(c)(8) sets when the period begins (for a removal case, when the NTA is filed with the court) and how the exemption is requested: no fee, in writing, submitted with the I-485, supported by documents. Under 8 CFR 245.1(c)(8)(v), an I-130 approved under the 204(g) exemption is "primary evidence" that the I-485 qualifies too, so build the petition record to that standard from the first page.
One 2025 change raises the stakes. USCIS updated the Policy Manual at Volume 6, Part B, Chapter 5 on August 1, 2025 (Policy Alert PA-2025-12) and made an I-130 interview mandatory where the marriage occurred while the beneficiary was in removal proceedings. Expect both of you to be interviewed at the Philadelphia Field Office on the 204(g) factors. After a final order, the reopening standard is Matter of Velarde-Pacheco, 23 I&N Dec. 253 (BIA 2002), which modified Matter of Arthur, 20 I&N Dec. 475 (BIA 1992), and still demands clear and convincing evidence of a bona fide marriage.
Are You Even Eligible? The 245(a) Traps Before the Judge
INA 245(a) requires that you were "inspected and admitted or paroled." The traps we see most often:
- Entry without inspection. If you crossed without inspection, you cannot adjust under 245(a) no matter how strong the marriage is, unless 245(i) applies (a petition or labor certification filed for you on or before April 30, 2001). That spouse is usually looking at consular processing with an I-601A waiver.
- The wave-through. If an officer at a port of entry let you pass without questions, Matter of Quilantan, 25 I&N Dec. 285 (BIA 2010), holds that you need "only prove procedural regularity" in the entry to be "admitted" for 245(a), so long as you did not falsely claim citizenship.
- Parole. Parole satisfies 245(a), but it also makes you an arriving alien, which sends the I-485 back to USCIS.
Two things that worry clients are not bars for a citizen's spouse. The 245(c) bars for unauthorized work or falling out of status do not apply to immediate relatives (8 CFR 245.1(b)(4) through (b)(6)), and unlawful presence does not bar adjustment from inside the United States, because the INA 212(a)(9)(B) bars are triggered by a departure.
Admissibility is the other half. The public charge ground at INA 212(a)(4) applies to every adjustment applicant, including one before a judge. The DHS rule, 91 FR 45324, took effect September 18, 2026 and governs USCIS adjudications; see our post on the public charge rule and the pending lawsuits. Immigration judges apply the statute and the Form I-864 requirement in INA 213A, and as of October 2026 EOIR has not adopted the DHS rule's framework by regulation. Prepare the financial record to the stricter standard anyway, using the 08/24/26 edition of Form I-864, the only edition accepted since October 1, 2026.
Married to a U.S. citizen and facing an immigration judge?
Your green card now runs through two agencies at once. We file the I-130 with USCIS, the I-485 with the court, and keep the removal case open long enough to win it.
Talk to a Green Card AttorneyOr call (484) 763-4984
Buying Time: Continuances, the Loss of Administrative Closure, and DHS Motions to Dismiss
Because the judge must wait for USCIS, the case needs a lawful way to wait. In October 2026 there are three, one of them mostly gone.
Continuances. Hashmi held that an unopposed motion to continue for a pending family petition "should generally be granted if approval of the visa petition would render him prima facie eligible for adjustment of status," and listed the factors for a contested one: DHS's response, whether the petition is prima facie approvable, statutory eligibility for adjustment, whether adjustment merits a favorable exercise of discretion, and the reason for the continuance. The Attorney General narrowed the lens in Matter of L-A-B-R-, 27 I&N Dec. 405 (A.G. 2018): the principal focus is the likelihood that the collateral relief will be granted and will materially affect the outcome. A citizen's spouse with a clean entry and a documented marriage scores well under both tests; a spouse with an entry problem does not.
Administrative closure. The tool that let a case rest off calendar while USCIS worked is largely gone. First the Board narrowed it: Matter of Ibarra-Vega, 29 I&N Dec. 476 (BIA 2026), held, in a U visa case, that closure over DHS objection is inappropriate where the benefit is not available and not likely to be available in the reasonably near future, and that "absent unique circumstances specific to an individual case, administrative closure in excess of 6 months is presumptively unreasonable." Then, on June 22, 2026, in State of Texas v. Department of Justice, No. 7:26-cv-00070-O (N.D. Tex.), Chief Judge Reed O'Connor entered a consent judgment declaring the 2024 rule that codified closure, 89 FR 46742 (May 29, 2024), "in excess of statutory authority and contrary to law," vacating it and enjoining its enforcement. Several cities and a legal aid group were denied intervention and have appealed to the Fifth Circuit (No. 26-10794); as of October 4, 2026 no court has stayed the judgment, and 8 CFR 1003.18(c), though still printed in the eCFR, has no force. Third Circuit precedent, Arcos Sanchez v. Attorney General, 997 F.3d 113 (3d Cir. 2021), rests closure on older regulations the Texas court did not address, so the argument survives in Philadelphia and Newark, but no spouse should plan a case around it.
DHS motions to dismiss. Under 8 CFR 1239.2(c), ICE counsel may move to dismiss on the grounds in 8 CFR 239.2(a), including that the NTA was "improvidently issued" or that continuing the case "is no longer in the best interest of the government." Dismissal sends the whole case back to USCIS. That was routine in 2022; in 2025 and 2026 it is not, and practitioner alerts from the National Immigration Project and the ILRC describe OPLA moving to dismiss cases so that ICE can arrest the respondent for expedited removal. Treat an unexpected government motion to dismiss with scrutiny. The termination provisions at 8 CFR 1003.18(d) fell with the rest of the 2024 rule. Our post on getting a removal case dismissed or terminated in 2026 covers what remains.
Building the I-485 Package for the Immigration Court
Same form, different logistics:
- File with the court and serve OPLA. The I-485 (09/18/26 edition), the I-864 (08/24/26 edition), any waiver, and the evidence are filed under the judge's deadline, with a copy served on ICE counsel.
- Two fees, two payees. Since H.R. 1 (Pub. L. 119-21, sec. 100013), an I-485 filed with or adjudicated by the immigration court carries two separate charges. The regular USCIS fee under the G-1055 schedule (biometrics included; see current USCIS filing fees) goes to USCIS: the judge hands you USCIS's "Instructions for Submitting Certain Applications in Immigration Court" (revised June 8, 2026), which direct you to send a copy of the application, the fee, and any G-28 to a designated USCIS service center. Separately, EOIR collects its own court fee for the I-485 under 91 FR 61447 (see current immigration court fees), paid through the EOIR Payment Portal, with the receipt filed with the court. Confirm the court's current payment practice before filing.
- File the receipt and biometrics confirmation with the court. The judge cannot grant adjustment until background checks are complete; skipping these steps is treated as abandonment.
- Medical exam. Form I-693 from a civil surgeon, sealed, by the court's deadline.
Build the evidence as if the merits hearing were a trial, because it is: both spouses testify, ICE counsel may cross-examine, and the marriage evidence, the sponsor's finances, and the equities are presented live.
If Your Spouse Is Detained
A detained spouse can still adjust before the judge, but custody comes first. For people arrested inside the United States after entering without inspection, DHS took the position in 2025 that INA 235(b)(2)(A) requires detention without a bond hearing, and the Board agreed in Matter of Yajure Hurtado, 29 I&N Dec. 216 (BIA 2025). The Third Circuit rejected that reading in Buele Morocho v. Warden (3d Cir. Aug. 28, 2026); our post on the Buele Morocho decision explains what to ask for. On October 1, 2026 the Supreme Court granted certiorari in Rhoney v. Barbosa da Cunha, No. 26-104, to decide the question nationally. Until it rules, Buele Morocho governs the Philadelphia, Elizabeth, and Newark courts.
Flag a pending I-130 to ICE counsel immediately; detained dockets move in weeks. ICE Policy 16021.1 (2010) lets its attorneys ask USCIS to expedite a petition that would provide an immediate basis for relief, with a 30-day target in detained cases; whether USCIS honors that target in 2026 varies, so make the request without relying on it. A paroled spouse is an arriving alien even when detained, so the I-485 still goes to USCIS.
Timing, Approval, and Denial: What the Judge's Order Does
Non-detained cases in Philadelphia are typically set for an individual hearing a year or more out, and a case waiting on an I-130 can be placed on a status docket, a periodic check-in rather than a merits date.
When the judge grants adjustment, 8 CFR 1245.2(a)(5)(ii) provides that "the applicant's permanent residence shall be recorded as of the date of the order approving the adjustment of status." USCIS produces the card after the order. If the marriage was under two years old on the date of the order, the residence is conditional under INA 216, and the I-751 clock starts that day.
If the judge denies the application, a Notice of Appeal to the Board (Form EOIR-26) must be received within 30 days, with the filing fee set under 91 FR 54211. The appeal keeps the removal order from being executed while it is pending. A spouse whose case also has an asylum component should read our post on affirmative versus defensive asylum before the merits hearing, since those applications are heard in the same proceeding.
What This Means in the Lehigh Valley
Removal cases for Allentown, Bethlehem, Easton, and Reading residents are heard at the Philadelphia Immigration Court, 900 Market Street, Suite 504, with ICE counsel in Suite 346. The same family's I-130 interview happens about two miles away at the USCIS Philadelphia Field Office, 30 North 41st Street. The two offices talk only through the file. Couples whose cases were filed in New Jersey appear at the Elizabeth or Newark courts under the same regulations.
Two local realities shape strategy. First, the Philadelphia non-detained calendar is long, giving USCIS time to approve the I-130; a well-supported Hashmi continuance request filed before the master calendar hearing keeps the judge's goodwill. Second, many Lehigh Valley respondents entered through a port of entry on parole in 2023 and 2024. Those spouses are arriving aliens: the I-485 goes to the USCIS lockbox, and the removal case must simply be kept open until USCIS decides. Filing with the wrong agency wastes the fee and months. Our removal defense practice handles both sides of these cases from one file.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can USCIS approve my green card while I am in removal proceedings?
Only if you are an arriving alien, meaning you were paroled into the United States rather than admitted. Under 8 CFR 1245.2(a)(1)(ii) and Matter of Yauri, USCIS keeps jurisdiction over a parolee's I-485 even during proceedings. Everyone else files the I-485 with the immigration judge under 8 CFR 1245.2(a)(1)(i). USCIS decides the I-130 in every case.
We got married after I received the Notice to Appear. Is the green card still possible?
Yes, but the standard is higher. INA 245(e)(3) and INA 204(g) require clear and convincing evidence that the marriage was entered in good faith and not to obtain immigration status. USCIS now requires an I-130 interview when the marriage took place during proceedings, and the exemption is requested in writing with the I-485 under 8 CFR 245.1(c)(8).
Can the judge decide my I-485 before USCIS approves the I-130?
No. The judge can accept the I-485 while the petition is pending, but an immigrant visa must be immediately available before adjustment is granted, and for a spouse that comes from the approved I-130. The case is usually continued under the Matter of Hashmi factors, or placed on a status docket, until USCIS decides.
Can my case be administratively closed while USCIS works on the petition?
Rarely, as of October 2026. The 2024 rule authorizing administrative closure was vacated on June 22, 2026 in State of Texas v. Department of Justice, and the BIA held in Matter of Ibarra-Vega that closure beyond six months is presumptively unreasonable. A continuance or status docket setting is the realistic request.
Who do I pay the I-485 fee to when I file with the court?
Both agencies. The regular USCIS fee goes to USCIS under the court's instruction sheet, and USCIS returns the fee receipt and biometrics notice that must be in the court record before the judge can grant the application. Separately, since H.R. 1, EOIR charges its own fee for an I-485 filed with the immigration court (91 FR 61447), paid through the EOIR Payment Portal.
Get Help With Adjustment of Status in Removal Proceedings
A spouse's green card in immigration court is two cases run as one: a petition at USCIS that has to be approved, and a removal case that has to be kept open, then won. Lehigh Valley Immigration Law LLC represents couples before the Philadelphia, Elizabeth, and Newark immigration courts and at the USCIS Philadelphia Field Office, handling the I-130, the I-485, and any bond hearing together. We offer a free bilingual consultation to map which agency holds which decision in your case. Call (484) 763-4984 or contact us online. No outcome can be guaranteed in any immigration case, but filing the right form with the right agency, on time, is within your control.